
The quarterly service review starts at ten. On one side of the table, the fleet manager has a list of complaints: the reach truck that stood for most of a week in August, the technician who arrived without the right part and the job card that took ten days to appear. On the other side, the service provider’s branch manager has a spreadsheet showing that almost every call was attended within the agreed time.
Both are telling the truth. By eleven, they are mostly arguing about whose truth counts.
Most supplier reviews go this way at least once. Not because anyone is acting in bad faith, but because each side arrives with a different record of the same three months, and the loudest memory tends to fill the gaps.
Memory is a poor reporting tool
People remember the breakdown that stopped a loading bay during the month-end rush. They forget the routine services that went exactly as planned. That is not a flaw in fleet managers. It is simply how memory works: pain is vivid and smooth service is invisible.
Suppliers have the opposite problem. Their records tend to show what they are measured on, which is often attendance. A technician on site within the agreed time looks good on a report, even if the machine then waited several days for a part.
Without a shared record, a supplier review becomes a negotiation between two partial stories. The usual outcome is a vague promise to “improve communication” and the same conversation next quarter.
Agree what is being measured before measuring it
Many disagreements in supplier reviews are really disagreements about definitions. When does a breakdown start: when the operator noticed it, when someone phoned it in or when the job was logged? When does it end: when the technician leaves the site, or when the machine is back at work?
Response time, downtime, first-time fix and job completion all sound clear until two parties calculate them differently. The contract may define some of them. Often it defines them loosely, or not at all.
A sensible first step is to agree the definitions in writing, ideally before the next period begins rather than halfway through a disputed review. Once both sides measure the same thing, the conversation can move from whose number is right to what the number means.
The contract is the yardstick, so keep it close
A supplier can only be fairly judged against what they actually agreed to. That sounds obvious, yet many reviews take place without anyone in the room having read the service level agreement since it was signed.
SLA commitments, exclusions, warranty terms, which sites and machines are covered and what counts as customer-caused damage all shape whether a delay was the supplier’s responsibility. A machine damaged in operation, or a site that could not give the technician access, is a different conversation from a call that was simply never attended.
Keeping the agreement, the equipment schedule and the service record connected means that question can be answered from the facts, not from whoever remembers the clause.
Evidence protects good suppliers too
It is tempting to see supplier performance records as a stick for the customer to wave. In practice, they are at least as useful to the supplier.
A service provider that attends promptly, records its findings, quotes quickly and closes jobs properly deserves to have that visible. When a machine has stood for a week, a clear record might show that the quotation went out on day one and the approval only arrived on day five. That is not an excuse. It is a fact that changes what needs fixing, and where.
Good relationships between fleets and their suppliers rest on trust, and trust grows faster when both sides can see the same history.
Look for patterns, not just incidents
One bad week is an incident. The same fault on the same model at three sites is a pattern. Reviews that focus only on the latest frustration tend to miss the patterns, which is usually where the real improvement sits.
The useful questions are often simple. Which sites see the most breakdowns, and is that down to the equipment, the application or the service? Are repeat repairs clustering around particular assets? Is work waiting on parts, on approvals or on access? Are planned services being completed when they fall due, or quietly slipping behind the breakdowns?
These questions only have answers if service events, downtime, costs and outcomes have been recorded consistently, against the asset, throughout the period.
Make the review a working meeting
A supplier review built on shared evidence changes its tone. Less time goes on reconstructing what happened and more on deciding what happens next.
The most useful reviews end with a short list of actions, each with an owner on one side of the table or the other, and a date to check progress. The next review then opens with those actions rather than a fresh set of grievances.
Where FMC supports supplier reviews
FMC is built with this kind of conversation in mind. For fleet customers, it brings assets, suppliers, service activity, compliance and costs into one view across every site, including technician performance, SLAs and contract compliance.
FMC Dashboards & Reporting turns recorded breakdowns, downtime, services, costs and technician activity into consistent reports, so supplier and SLA reviews can draw on information both sides recognise. FMC Contract Management keeps SLA commitments, warranties, exclusions and equipment coverage in one accessible record, alongside the operation they govern.
The records support the discussion. Judging performance fairly, and deciding what to do about it, remains a matter for the people on both sides of the table.
Preparing for your next supplier review
Before the next meeting, it is worth checking a few things:
- Do both sides use the same definitions for response time, downtime and completion?
- Has anyone reread the SLA, the exclusions and the list of covered machines?
- Can each disputed incident be traced from the first call to the closed job?
- Which repeat issues have appeared across sites or assets this period?
- Which actions from the last review were completed, and by whom?
If most of the meeting would still rely on what people remember, start with the record.
A supplier review should settle what happened, so the meeting can be about what happens next.

